Best Picks: 8 Used Small Cars to Buy in 2025

Used Cars in New Jersey

Best Used Compact cars: Top 8 Small Car Picks for 2025

Find the perfect fit!

Subscribe now and unlock exclusive deals on used cars, along with the latest updates and insights delivered directly to your inbox!

Used Car for Sale

Or Sell / Trade Your Car

If you’re shopping for a compact car, the used market offers some of the best deals. On average, vehicles lose about 25% of their value within the first year, meaning you can save significantly by choosing a used car that’s just a year old.

While used car prices have generally been climbing, compact car prices have bucked the trend, thanks to the growing preference for trucks and SUVs.

For buyers, this creates an excellent opportunity. With an abundance of compact options and declining prices, now is a great time to find a deal. Below, we’ve highlighted 8 standout used compact cars that offer both value and savings, thanks to recent price drops.

1. 2017 Honda Civic

Car Key Points

Amongst the best selling small cars
4 door sedan and hatchback, two door coupe – model for everyone
Standard 158-hp 2.0-liter inline four-cylinder engine
1.5-liter inline four turbo is truly a gem
Up to 34 MPG combined (2.0-liter); Up to 36 MPG combined (1.6-liter turbo)
The turbo engine is standard on the hatch and offered on EX-T or above trims in the sedan
Fun to drive manual available
High performance models – Si and Type R
Amongst the best selling compact car

Available 7-inch touchscreen infotainment system with Apple CarPlay/Android Auto connectivity
Available Honda Sensing package adds active driver safety aids

Overview

The Honda Civic, in many ways, is like that kid at school who excels in everything. The 10th generation, making its debut in 2016, completely reshaped the small car scene. It boasts a captivating design, surprising comfort for a compact car, and a driving experience that leaves you thoroughly satisfied – ticking all the boxes for an ideal ride.

What truly sets the Civic apart is its remarkable versatility, offering a model to suit every taste.The Popular 205-hp Si model or the tire-squeaking 306-hp Type R are surely at the peak of the spectrum, but even the regular models are plenty satisfying.

The standard 158-hp 2-liter four-cylinder engine gets the job done. However, the 1.5-litre turbocharged with its extra kick in performance along with superb fuel economy is a recommended upgrade. Driving enthusiasts should be looking at the manual, which is offered on certain sedan trims and a standard fitment on all the hatchback models.

The 2017 Civic’s armor is nearly flawless, save for the somewhat irksome touchscreen infotainment system. However, it’s far from a deal-breaker, especially when considering the Civic’s solid safety features and its well-established reputation for dependability.

In the end, whether you go for the four-door sedan, the two-door coupe, or the four-door hatchback, one thing remains clear: the 2017 Honda Civic stands out as one of the best used compact cars out there.

Pros:

The turbo 1.5 offers impressive fuel efficiency and performance
Skillfully blends ride comfort with athletic handling
Abundance of advanced technology and safety features
Upscale and roomy interior

Cons:

Confusing and slow-to-respond touchscreen interface
Frustratingly vigilant forward collision warning system

2. 2019 Mazda 3

Car Key Points

186-hp 2.5-liter inline four-cylinder engine
Up to 30 MPG combined (EPA-rated)
Opt for the sedan for enhanced practicality
Earned the prestigious Top Safety Pick award from IIHS
Optional All-wheel drive available from the Select package onward for an additional $1,400
Avoid the base trim and go for at least the Select trim to enjoy a range of valuable features, including ADAS tech
The Premium trim models have interiors comparable to luxury cars
Infotainment system screen lacks touchscreen functionality and is operated through a rotary controller
13.2 cubic feet of cargo volume falls short compared to classmates

Overview

In 2025, not making a crossover your de facto choice seems like a tough job. However, the Mazda 3 effortlessly justifies that decision.

The fourth generation Mazda 3 introduced for the 2019 model year is a near-perfect compact car that offers a lot of bang for your buck.. The sleek silhouette on the outside paired with the incredibly high-class interior gives off a near luxury-car vibe on a bargain.

Equipped with a lively 186-hp 2.5-liter four-cylinder engine across all models, the Mazda 3’s generations-long prowess in handling is never underutilized. The powertrain responds adeptly to throttle inputs and you will love the precision of the chassis and steering during corners.

For those in colder climates, the 2019 Mazda 3 brings an added advantage, being one of the few used compact cars with all-wheel-drive.

However, it’s not without drawbacks. The back seat might feel a bit cramped, cargo capacity is average, and if you opt for the hatchback, be mindful that rear visibility could be a concern. Additionally, while Mazda has equipped the car with impressive tech and infotainment features, the frustrating aspect is that the infotainment system isn’t touch-operated; you can only control it using a rotary controller.

Despite these limitations, if you seek an upscale, enjoyable, and efficient compact sedan or hatchback, the 2019 Mazda 3 is one of the best used small cars in the grand scheme of things.

Pros:

All-wheel drive (AWD) option available
High-quality interior materials
Exceptionally comfortable and supportive seats
Engaging and spirited handling
Presents a more upscale appearance compared to competitors.

Cons:

Limited rear legroom
Reduced rear visibility in the hatchback version
Key features limited to specific trim levels.
Cargo space falls short compared to other compact cars

3. 2020 Toyota Corolla

Car Key Points

139-hp 1.8-liter inline four or a 169-hp 2.0-liter inline four engine
Smaller engine gets EPA-rated 33 mpg while the 2.0-liter gets 35 mpg combined with automatic transmission.
Hybrid model is rated at 52 mpg combined
Standard Toyota Safety Sense-P driver-assist suite
Solid reputation for reliability
Standard 7-inch and available 8-inch touchscreen infotainment system
Available six-speed manual transmission on the SE trim
Hybrid model is available only in LE trim
Hybrid Corolla is powered by a 1.8-liter four-cylinder gas engine plus two electric motor-generators (121-hp combined)
Mileage

Overview

Consider recommending a car, and the Toyota Corolla easily finds its way into the conversation. Affordable, safe, and reliable, the Corolla has been a perennial favorite for commuting and daily duties in the US.

Previous generations, though popular in sales, lacked personality, performance, and refinement. The 12th generation, introduced in 2020, shatters those old perceptions

The 2020 Toyota Corolla boasts a sharper exterior, swaps lackluster materials for an inviting interior that goes beyond expectations, delivers a pleasant ride, and is loaded with a plethora of standard tech and safety features.

The Corolla lineup, available in both a four-door hatchback and a sedan, offers a diverse range of personalities, including an incredibly efficient hybrid model.

Regardless of your choice within the Corolla lineup, the front seats offer comfort and support, accommodating taller passengers with ample headroom and legroom. While the sedan excels in rear passenger space, the trunk size is slightly smaller than average.

Standard powertrain is a meager 139-hp 1.8-liter four-cylinder engine mated to a CVT transmission. On the SE and XSE variants, the more potent 169-hp 2.0-liter four-cylinder engine, though still not topping the charts in its class, manages to offer excellent fuel economy.

The Corolla lineup also includes a super-efficient hybrid powertrain inherited from the Prius. The 2020 Corolla Hybrid boasts an impressive EPA-estimated 53 mpg in the city and 52 on the highway. However, it’s only available in a single trim and offers modest acceleration.

Pros:

Extensive list of standard advanced safety features
Well-appointed cabin with high-quality materials
Comfortable ride quality
Impressive fuel economy numbers

Cons:

Lack of Android Auto
Even Sporty trims may be a bit sluggish and lack excitement
Limited rear-seat headroom compared to more spacious competitors
Hybrid limited to a single, rather basic LE trim

4. 2020 Kia Forte

Car Key Points

Regular models get a 147-hp 2.0-liter Inline Four
Up to MPG (City – MPG / Highway – MPG)
Base get six-speed manual transmission as standard; CVT standard on other trims (except GT)
GT trim gets a 201-hp 1.6-liter Turbo four-cylinder
Solid 85/100 reliability rating from JD Power
Well-finished interior
Standard 8-inch touchscreen with Apple CarPlay / Android Auto connectivity
Standard driver assistance features
Top safety pick award from IIHS

Overview

While the Kia Forte might not compete head-to-head with the athleticism of a Mazda 3 or match the refined ride of a Honda Civic, its forte lies in playing the value game exceptionally well.

Redesigned for the 2019 model year, the Forte brings together eye-catching aesthetics and a comfortable, high-quality interior. However, what truly distinguishes it is the impressive array of standard features, including advanced driver assistance technologies. Whether you go for the base model or opt for a higher trim, the Kia Forte outshines competitors by offering more equipment for the price.

At the top of the ladder is the201-hp Forte GT, but again, it sits at a lower price than other sporty small sedans. Even the standard 147-hp 2.0 liter engine on the regular models feels stronger than its specifications suggest. It delivers a satisfying punch around town and accelerates well on the freeway, though the CVT automatic transmission lacks refinement. In routine driving, the Forte exhibits decent confidence, but there’s room for improvement in terms of ride comfort.

In summary, the 2020 Kia Forte distinguishes itself with its stylish aesthetics and an impressive array of tech and safety features—all without an exorbitant price tag.

Pros:

Attractive exterior design
Impressive interior finish and abundance of features for the price
Impressive fuel economy estimates
Generous warranty coverage
User-friendly technology interface

Cons:

Stiff ride quality
Limited back seat space compared to some rivals
Non-GT trims may lack excitement
So-so visibility

5. 2017 Chevrolet Cruze

Car Key Points

The long-distance cruiser of the class
153-hp 1.4-liter turbo or 137-hp 1.6-liter turbo diesel
EPA-Rated 52 mpg on the highway with Diesel and up to 40 mpg with the gas engine
Originally the only diesel option with a manual transmission and price under $30,000 in USA
Standard six-speed manual transmission and optional six-speed automatic
Diesel models have a nine-speed automatic available
Standard 7-inch and available 8-inch touchscreen infotainment system
Standard 4G LTE Wi-Fi hotspot, and Apple CarPlay and Android Auto connectivity
Host of standard safety features
Available active safety features from LT trim
Diesel is available only LT trim and sedan bodystyle

Overview

The Chevrolet Cruze often flies under the radar, but it’s a compact car with a host of impressive qualities. In its second generation (2016-2019), the Cruze manages to embody the characteristics of a pricier comfortable sedan within an affordable compact package – who doesn’t love that! This translates to a roomy and comfortable cabin, an exceptionally quiet and refined ride, and a range of standard features, all without breaking the bank.

What elevates the Cruze to an excellent long-distance road trip companion is its outstanding fuel economy. The 1.6-liter turbocharged diesel engine, offering up to 52 mpg on the highway, makes the 2017 Cruze one of the most fuel-efficient non-hybrid cars ever produced.

Even with the standard 153-hp turbocharged 1.4-liter four-cylinder, you’ll find it sufficiently lively and efficient. We suggest prioritizing the six-speed automatic over the manual transmission.

The Cruze exudes confidence on the road, feeling more stable than its dimensions might suggest. Its supple ride, relaxed handling, comfortable seats, and impressively quiet interior collectively establish it as the long-distance cruiser in its class.During road trips, you will also love the upscale cabin and high-tech features.

Despite its compact size, the Cruze boasts cargo space comparable to many mid-size sedans. Tying it all together is a suite of available active safety features and an impressive 5-star crash test rating from the NHTSA.

Check out an in-depth guide of a used 2019 Chevy Cruze.

Pros:

Attractive cabin, particularly with the two-tone color scheme.
Ample rear-seat legroom
Abundance of appealing convenience and technology features
Impressive highway efficiency with the diesel, boasting 52 mpg.
Quiet cabin and very comfortable ride quality
Intuitive infotainment system

Cons:

So-so acceleration with gas engine
Engine stop-start can’t be switched off
Lack of cruise control on the L or LS trims

6. 2019 Volkswagen Jetta

Car Key Points

Fully redesigned for 2019 (Seventh generation Jetta)
147-hp 1.4-liter Inline Four Turbo
Excellent EPA-ratings of up to 34 MPG combined
Six-speed manual on base; standard eight-speed automatic on every other trim.
Available high-performance GLI version
Five-star crash test rating from NHTSA
Available driver assistance features right from the base trim
Base trim’s price undercuts rivals but gets sufficient features
SEL and SEL premium give a taste of luxury
Standard 6.5-inch touchscreen and available 8-inch display infotainment system

Overview

If you prioritize sensibility, comfort, efficiency, and refinement over thrilling driving experiences, the 2019 Volkswagen Jetta makes for a compelling choice. The 2019 model witnessed the debut of the fully redesigned seventh generation of the Jetta, representing a significant leap forward from its predecessor.

With an expanded frame, the 2019 Jetta flaunts a smart interior design and ample accommodations. The exterior follows suit with distinctive styling, featuring sharp character lines, an enlarged grille, and a commanding road presence.

While the feature content becomes richer as you progress through the trims, every Jetta model is equipped with a snappy touchscreen-based infotainment system that supports Apple CarPlay and Android Auto. Gesture controls add a touch of sophistication, and the Driver Assistance package is also available right from the base trim.

The JLI is the hotcake of the Jetta lineup, but the regular 2019 Jetta is powered by a decently powerful 1.4-liter turbocharged inline-four engine. The Jetta is satisfying – not in terms of driving fun but in fuel economy terms (34 mpg combined).

Comparatively, the Golf hatchback may have a sportier edge, but the Jetta shines with its smoother ride and heightened refinement—a significant plus for those seeking a family sedan.

Pros:

Exceptional fuel efficiency
More practical and refined than the Golf
Responsive performance at city speeds
Ride quality comparable to more expensive sedans

Cons:

Top-tier features limited to higher models
Mediocre passing power and lesser driver engagement compared to the Golf
Manual transmission exclusive to the base model
Grabby brakes at low speeds
Cabin feels more plasticky compared classmates

7. 2016 Chevrolet Volt

Car Key Points

Completely redesigned for 2016
18.4-kWh lithium-ion battery
1.5-liter inline-4 engine (drives generator only)
Twin electric motors drives the front wheel (149 hp combined)
Impressive 53 miles of all-electric range and 420 miles of combined range
Earns EPA-Estimated 42 mpg combined on gasoline engine and 106/102 MPGe (all-electric, mpg equivalent)
Top Safety Pick+ (IIHS) and Five-star crash test rating (NHTSA)
Optional Driver Confidence 1 and 2 package (ADAS) on Premier trim
Robust Hybrid powertrain
Claimed 0-60 mph in about 8 seconds
A full recharge takes 4.5 hours using a 240-volt charger or approximately 13 hours with a standard 120-volt plug
Host of standard tech and comfort features

Overview

Originally introduced in 2010 and significantly upgraded in 2016, the Chevy Volt stands out as a trailblazer in plug-in hybrid technology, consistently setting the standard for others to follow. GM’s vision for the Volt was clear from the start – to provide drivers the freedom to navigate urban areas like an electric vehicle (EV) without the common concern of range anxiety.

This wasn’t a mere marketing ploy. In a segment where plug-in hybrids typically offer around 20 miles of all-electric range, the 2016 Volt delivers an exceptional 53 miles of guilt-free electric driving. This translates to covering almost 90% of your daily commutes without tapping into a single drop of fuel.

Even when the gas engine comes into play, the Volt’s quiet 1.5-liter engine only requires regular-grade gasoline and achieves an EPA-estimated 42 mpg combined.

But the 2016 Volt isn’t just a standout green car. Its sleek exterior, attractive interior, user-friendly features, and high crash safety ratings make it an all-around impressive vehicle. Plus, it provides a satisfying driving experience for a plug-in hybrid.

Read our detailed guide on the 2019 Chevrolet Volt

Pros:

Incredible electric range of 53 miles
Impressively quiet with a smooth power delivery
Low to negligible fuel costs, coupled with minimal range anxiety
Earns high safety ratings, and features numerous available active safety features
Surprisingly fun for a green car
Functional and straightforward interior layout
Generous array of standard features

Cons:

The fifth seat is barely usable.
Longer charging times due to a slow 3.6-kW charger
Driver assistance features confined to the Premier trim
Interior material quality is less impressive

8. 2017 Subaru Impreza

Car Key Points

152-hp 2.0-liter Flat Four Engine
All-weather capability with standard all-wheel drive
Top Safety Pick+ award from IIHS
Strong reputation for reliability
Hatch has better trunk space than the sedan
Earns an EPA-rated 32 MPG combined with the CVT and 27 MPG with the manual
Well-calibrated CVT improves initial response
Standard 6.5-inch touchscreen infotainment system and available 8.0-inch unit
Every model gets Apple CarPlay and Android Auto connectivity
Available Subaru EyeSight driver assist tech (Limited trim)

Overview

The 2017 Subaru Impreza stands out as one of the rare all-wheel-drive cars under $20,000, making it a true gem for drivers who face varying weather conditions. However, the fifth-generation Impreza, introduced in the 2017 model year, doesn’t solely rely on its all-wheel drive to win over buyers.

Beyond its all-weather prowess, the 2017 Impreza brings an unexpected level of practicality to the compact car category. Its increased size, compared to the previous generation, enhances the already spacious cabin. The cabin itself is thoughtfully designed, complemented by a generous array of standard features, including user-friendly infotainment technology.

The 2017 Impreza is obviously no rally hot rod but it shares its Subaru Global Platform with the WRX, and handles pretty confidently. Thankfully, it doesn’t come at the compromise of comfort as the car adeptly cushions you from the jolts and bumps of the road. Top safety ratings and an array of available active safety features further strengthen the Impreza’s appeal.

There are some shortcomings though, the 152-hp 2.0L F4 engine feels sluggish on the open roads and interior quality still lags behind segment leaders. However, if you’re in the market for an affordable and sure-footed AWD compact sedan that delivers stability and confidence in all driving conditions, the Impreza remains a standout choice.

Looking for more affordable all-weather options? Check out best all-wheel drive cars under a budget

Pros: